Obsessed with Becca Tilley’s Engagement Ring? These Lookalikes Are Just as Gorgeous

Becca Tilley’s elongated cushion-cut engagement ring from Hayley Kiyoko is turning heads—here are the best lookalike styles to shop if you’re dreaming of a similar sparkle.

When Hayley Kiyoko popped the question to longtime love Becca Tilley, she did so with a seriously swoon-worthy sparkler. The ring—an elongated cushion-cut diamond set in a timeless cathedral band with a hidden halo—was custom designed by Ring Concierge and is estimated to be worth around $300,000.

“The design features what appears to be a 5ct elongated cushion cut diamond set on a sleek, understated gold band. Becca Tilley’s ring is a perfect example of how a classic silhouette can feel fresh and modern,” says Jennifer Gandia, co-owner of New York City jeweler Greenwich St. Jewelers. “The elongated cushion cut has a romantic, vintage feel, but when paired with a minimal gold band, it becomes effortlessly contemporary.”

“Cushion cuts have been a beloved shape for years, but the elongated variation is having a moment — especially for those looking for a softer alternative to emerald cuts or pear shape,” she adds. “Set vertically, the stone draws the eye and flatters the finger, creating a timeless yet distinctive look that’s both elegant and personal.”

If you’re as obsessed with the elegant-yet-modern design as we are (and want the look without the six-figure price tag), we’ve rounded up stunning lookalike engagement rings that channel the same romantic vibe.

Baxter Hidden Halo 2.52ct Cushion Diamond Engagement Ring by G.St Ceremony from Greenwich St. Jewelers, starting price $32,600

‘Ray' Diamond Emerald Cut Ring by Bario Neal, starting price $2,920

‘The Serena' engagement ring by Taylor Custom Rings, starting price $1,710

Thin + Simple Solitaire Engagement Ring With Crisscut® Cushion Cut Diamond by Goodstone, price upon request

Radiant Cut Tulip Basket Cathedral Classic Solitaire Engagement Ring by With Clarity, starting price $6,219

4 Ct Radiant Lab Diamond & .10 Ctw Diamond Secret Halo Solitaire Ring by Slate & Tell, starting price $2,529.45

‘The Eri' ring by Taylor Custom Rings, starting price $2,085

See also

FashionShopping Deals & Steals

Saturday Shopping: Fall Fashion, Killer Kicks and Stunning Stationery Extras

Cover photo courtesy of Greenwich St. Jewelers

Related

20 Engagement Ring Dishes to Keep Your New Bling Shiny and Safe!

From the moment you slip that shiny new ring on your finger, everything changes. There’s a wedding to plan, your SO suddenly becomes your fiancé/e and now you have a new piece of jewelry, likely more expensive and precious than anything else in your collection, that you have to take care of! Whether you’re an avid jewelry wearer or prefer to keep it simple, tossing your accessories on the nightstand or on the floor as you collapse on the bed […]

Wood You Be Mine? Wooden Rings to Say “I Do” With

After swooning over the gorgeous wood rings in the Chicago World's Fair styled shoot, I went on a hunt to find some of the most gorgeous timber finger adornments out there. Etsy, of course, proved a treasure trove for such an endeavor … so much so that I had about 70 tabs open before I realized what a rabbit hole I'd fallen down. Wood rings are great for those who can't wear metal (say, electricians) or who simply want something […]

Guide to Getting Engaged: Engagement Ring Styles 101

Whether you're looking to pop the question or browsing for your own ring finger (p.s. no shame in forwarding this article to your partner for a not-so-subtle hint!), we know finding the ring can feel overwhelming, which is why we've teamed up with jeweler Taylor & Hart to create an in-depth resource featuring a series of articles to help guide.  One of the first design decisions you'll need to make is what engagement ring style you want. From classic solitaire to something more unique like a multiple band stack, there's a […]